Introducing the Sampler Sammie Box from Carisa’s Cake Shop!
 
Enjoy one dozen of Carisa’s signature Sammies, featuring a delicious assortment of our most-loved flavors. Each sammie is baked completely from scratch using high-quality ingredients, including organic flour that’s locally milled.
 
Flavors Included:
Homemade Oreo
A rich, chewy chocolate cookie filled with creamy whipped vanilla buttercream. A nostalgic classic that’s even better when served with a cold glass of milk.
 
The Mapledoodle
Our best-selling sammie! Two buttery snickerdoodle cookies made with our organic, locally milled flour sandwich a fluffy maple buttercream. Warm, cozy, and completely irresistible — this one is unlike anything you’ve ever tasted.
 
Chocolate Caramel
Carisa’s personal favorite. A decadent double-chocolate cookie filled with chocolate buttercream and a hidden center of Carisa’s signature salted caramel sauce. Pure indulgence.
 
Plus a Mystery Flavor
A surprise sammie handpicked by Carisa from what we’re baking in the shop.
 
Everything is made by hand in small batches right here in our little shop, using simple ingredients and time-honored baking methods. Because of this, items on our website tend to sell out quickly.
 
Thank you for supporting our small-town bakery and the quality we proudly stand behind.
Please read our Shipping Info page for shipment details.